by secondary crossmember i'm assuming you mean the one that sits sideways uder the car, not the one that goes from front to back of the engine bay. and yes the secondary crossmember has to come out to remove the downpipe. I had problems taking this out too, so i went to a show and had the bolts taken off with an impact gun. if thats not an option for you, just get a big breaker bar and if thats still not enough put a bit pipe over the breaker bar for more leaverage. hope that helps